How Much Does Replacing A Roof Cost In Central Pennsylvania?

August 9, 2024

Most homeowners spend anywhere between six thousand to twenty thousand on a new roof. Replacing the entire roof versus repairing it can be more cost effective in the long run, especially for older homes with extensive damage that may require a full roof replacement. Yes, the price range or cost is quite large. In this article, we'll break down what you should watch out for when it comes to your roof replacement cost. Here’s a bulleted list below that highlights what you may expect from an estimate perspective.


  • Small Home: $6,000-$10,000; Typically between 1,000 and 1,500 square feet.
  • Medium-Sized Home: $10,000-$15,000; Typically between 1,500 and 2,500 square feet.
  • Large or Complex Home: $15,000+; More than 2,500 square feet or with complex designs.


Replacing your roof is a valuable investment that helps maintain the long-term condition of your home. Understanding the average roof replacement cost is crucial for homeowners planning this significant investment. Depending on the materials you choose, a new roof can last between 20 and 100 years, providing reliable protection for your home. In addition to the practical benefits, a new roof can also enhance your home’s appeal to potential buyers, potentially increasing its market value when the time comes to sell. In this article, we’ll explore information as well as common questions people ask when it comes to replacing a roof and the cost involved.

A house with a window and a brown roof replaced by Sunnyside Roofing LLC in Lancaster PA.

Square Footage & Required Roofing Materials

The cost of a roof replacement is primarily influenced by two key factors: the square footage of your roof and the materials you choose. Each home is unique, so the final cost can vary significantly. As a general guideline, you can expect to pay between $6,000 and $10,000 for a small home, $10,000 to $15,000 for a medium-sized home, and $15,000 or more for a larger or more complex home.


Square footage plays a major role because larger roofs require more materials and labor, which increases the overall cost. However, the choice of roofing materials can also have a substantial impact on the price. The most cost-effective material option is an asphalt shingle roof, which is popular for its affordability and durability. Asphalt shingle roofs are also known for their longevity and low maintenance needs, making them a suitable choice for various climates. But there are also premium materials available that offer greater longevity and enhanced aesthetic appeal, though at a higher price point.


Given the variety of options and the specific needs of each home, it’s important to get an accurate estimate tailored to your situation. That’s why we recommend scheduling a consultation with Sunnyside Roofing. We pride ourselves on offering fair and transparent pricing to all our customers. During your consultation, we’ll provide a detailed estimate and help you determine which materials are the best fit for your budget and roofing requirements. Our goal is to ensure you get the best value for your investment while meeting your home’s needs and aesthetic preferences.

Common Types of Roofing for Replacement Projects

Asphalt Shingles - Comprised of a mix of fiberglass, asphalt, and mineral composite. They have long been a very popular choice for homeowners because of their affordability and durability. They cost anywhere between $4.25-$8.25 per square foot, and are also easy to install, which cuts down on labor costs. There are many different types of asphalt singles available. Some designer asphalt shingles have been created to replicate the look of a metal or wood shingle but without the high cost. For example, GAF Camelot II shingles have an artisan-crafted slate-like shape and custom palette to conjure the romance of European architecture. Asphalt is not the only material out there, though. Other materials that are often used include: Roof installation costs can vary depending on the material chosen and the complexity of the process.


Galvanized Steel - Metal roofs, including galvanized steel, are known for their durability and resistance to extreme weather conditions. Galvanized steel roofs are made from a steel core with a zinc coating to provide years of durability. They cost between $8-$12.65 per square foot.


Stainless Steel - One of the most premium metal roofing materials, stainless steel roofs are very rust-resistant and durable. They are more expensive, at $10-$16 per square foot; however, they protect your home for 50-100 years.


Slate or Stone - Slate and stone are beautiful but cost quite a bit more than materials like metal or wood. They are highly durable, fireproof, and resistant to high winds and extreme temperatures. Slate or stone shingles cost between $12-$16 per square foot.


Copper - Copper is the most extravagant roofing option, but a copper roof lasts much longer than traditional roofs. It also adds an elegant touch to the curb appeal of your home. Copper shingles cost $14-$25 per square foot.

Additional Factors Influencing Roof Replacement Costs

Although square footage and materials are the two main factors in the cost of a roof replacement; however, other features of your roof may also affect the cost due to increased labor and time. The condition of the existing roof can also significantly impact the overall cost of replacement. The slope of a roof, valleys, peaks, and dormers can all affect the final cost of replacing a roof. These architectural features can increase the complexity and time required for a roof replacement, leading to higher costs. Also, penetrations in the roof, such as from pipes or chimneys, can have an impact on the final cost. Each penetration in your roof adds complexity to the replacement process, which can drive up costs due to the need for additional sealing and flashing. Additionally, unexpected roof repairs can arise, making it essential to budget for these potential costs.

This is a great question! There are a number of factors to consider whether or not if now is the right time to replace your roof. Overall, you should consider replacing your roof if it’s nearing the end of its lifespan, showing visible damage like cracked or missing shingles, or if you notice leaks or water stains inside your home. Other indicators include rising energy bills, extensive moss or algae growth, and frequent repairs. Storm damage is another reason to evaluate your roof’s condition. Additionally, if you’re planning to sell your home, a new roof can enhance curb appeal and boost resale value. Regular inspections by a professional can help you determine if a roof replacement is necessary to maintain your home’s integrity. While considering these factors, it's also important to weigh the risks and benefits of a diy roof replacement, as it requires specialized knowledge and tools, and mistakes can lead to dangerous situations or costly repairs.

Why Choose Sunnyside Roofing of Lancaster PA?

At Sunnyside Roofing, we are dedicated to offering fair and transparent pricing to all our customers. Selecting a reputable roofing company will ensure quality workmanship and fair pricing when it comes to roof cost. As an Amish roofing contractor, we take pride in our commitment to quality craftsmanship and honest business practices. We believe that every homeowner deserves to understand the costs involved in a roof replacement, which is why we offer a free consultation. During this consultation, we’ll help you navigate your options and choose the best materials that fit your budget and roofing needs. Our goal is to ensure you receive the highest value for your investment while upholding the integrity and tradition of Amish workmanship.


Is your home or business local to Lancaster or central PA? The best way to find out how much a new roof will cost is to get an estimate by scheduling a free consultation today. We beat most of our competitors because we keep our overhead low and offer a no obligation inspection and estimate. Give us a call today!

Other Roofing Articles You May Like

sunnyside roofing llc team and truck in lancaster pa
February 12, 2025
Explore how Lancaster County’s weather impacts roofs and why hiring a local roofing contractor who knows our unique climate is the best decision you can make.
A large brick house with a black metal roof
January 14, 2025
Discover 5 key roofing facts for Lancaster, PA homeowners. Learn about costs, materials, lifespan, and energy efficiency to make informed roofing decisions.
A large house sits in the middle of a grassy field in Lancaster with a new roof
December 11, 2024
A pro roofer can easily spot damage or signs of wear that you may have missed and advise you on which repairs may be needed. Local to Lancaster? We can help!
See More Posts

Request Service Using This Form

Blog Contact Form

Share by: