Asphalt Shingle Vs. Metal Roofs in Lancaster PA

Whether replacing an existing roof or building a new home, one of the most important decisions a homeowner will make is deciding which roofing material to use on their new roof. There are many different types of roofing materials on the market today, but two of the most popular are asphalt shingles and metal roofs. The material you pick for your roof will have a long-term impact on the look, feel, and value of your home. In this article, we will discuss the benefits of both and compare their cost, maintenance, and durability to help you decide which is the best option for your home.

Metal roofing comes in large flat sheets and offers strength and durability while requiring minimal maintenance. Asphalt shingles are made from a mix of fiberglass, asphalt, and mineral composite. They are a popular choice for homeowners because of their affordability. There are many different types of asphalt shingles available. Some designer asphalt shingles have been created to replicate the look of metal or wood shingles but without the high cost.

Cost

A metal roof is significantly more expensive than asphalt shingles, often costing twice as much. The average asphalt shingle roof costs $4.25-$4.95 per square foot, including installation. The cost of a metal roof depends on the type of metal. Here are the average costs per square foot with installation:

• Aluminum shingles: $8.50-$13.75
• Copper shingles: $21–$39.70
• Corrugated metal panels: $5.50–$11.50
• Standing-seam metal panels: $10–$17.05
• Steel shingles: $8–$12.65

The initial cost is higher for metal roofs. But initial costs are not the only consideration.

Maintenance

Roof maintenance largely depends on climate and how well the roof was installed. In the northeast, we have harsh winter weather, as well as hot and humid summers - both of which can cause issues for your roof. Regular roof maintenance is an essential part of ensuring the longevity of both asphalt and metal roofs. That being said, a metal roof typically requires less maintenance since they’re less vulnerable to moisture. One thing to consider with metal roofs, however, is denting. Trimming tree branches on your property can help minimize the threat of a fallen branch causing damage to your metal roof.

The maintenance involved in keeping up an asphalt roof is considerably more involved. Regular roof inspections can be helpful in checking for loose, cracked shingles, damaged flashing, and other instances of water pooling which can lead to leaks and rot.

Durability

Metal roofs may cost more upfront, but they last significantly longer than an asphalt shingle roof. Metal roofs typically come with 30-50-year warranties and often outlast their warranties by 10-20 years. They are incredibly durable. Asphalt shingles come with a 15-30 year warranty. And they are vulnerable to dampness from heavy rain or snow. Even with proper maintenance, an asphalt shingle roof will probably need to be replaced at some point (unless you move after just a few years), and saving for a new roof should be something to consider in your budget.

Other Considerations

Asphalt roofs are quieter and easier to install. Metal roofs can be noisy in the rain and are more difficult to install (which is also reflected in the installation cost being higher). However, metal roofs are more eco-friendly and can be recycled, whereas asphalt shingles end up in the landfill once they’ve come to the end of their lifespan. In conclusion, metal roofs can be a great option if you have enough money upfront to invest in your roof. They are highly durable and require little maintenance. A metal roof can also be a very attractive and classy option. However, for many homeowners, asphalt shingles are a more realistic option. They are highly customizable, can be purchased in a variety of colors, and can be installed quickly. If you are deciding which material is best for your home, our expert roofers can help you decide what makes the most sense for your needs.